2023 Subaru Crosstrek vs 2023 Honda HR-V

A blue 2023 Subaru Crosstrek and a black 2023 Honda HR-V angled away from each other on a white background

When choosing a subcompact SUV, you want to be able to take advantage of ample space and convenience inside, paired up nicely with easy driving dynamics and plenty of capabilities on the road. Two top options in the industry are the Subaru Crosstrek and Honda HR-V, both sporting exceptional handling and control, superior safety features, and spacious cabins to accommodate everyone and everything joining you for the ride.

When you want to take this a step further and venture out into challenging environments with confidence and have the peace of mind that your vehicle is one of the most reliable around, Subaru is the brand to pick, but don’t count the HR-V out just yet. It showcases a wonderful driving demeanor, plus loads of dependable features to stand up to much of the competition, but is it enough to compete with the Crosstrek? When comparing the 2023 Subaru Crosstrek vs 2023 Honda HR-V, you’ll soon realize which subcompact SUV is ready to deliver the better ride.

New for 2023, the Subaru Crosstrek is available in a Special Edition model, which features 17-inch wheels, dark gray exterior trimmings, and an exclusive color palette inside and out. The HR-V enters a brand-new generation for 2023, showcasing a new design based on the popular Civic model, as well as more power and a more engaging performance than its predecessors. In the areas of performance, safety, and versatility, which subcompact travel companion will be able to provide you with the ride you desire? Here at Williams Subaru, we want to help you choose the best small-size traveler for your unique journey, so let’s delve into what each model will bring to your ride.

     2023 Subaru Crosstrek
VS      
2023 Honda HR-V 
$23,645[a]
MSRP    
$23,800
152
Horsepower (hp)    
158
145
Torque (lb-ft)    
138
55.3
Max Cargo Volume (cu.ft.)    
55.1

A white 2023 Subaru Crosstrek parked in front of a modern home on a mountain

Performance

Powertrain Lineup

To say that you have options when it comes to your engine choice in the 2023 Subaru Crosstrek is a massive understatement. With three powertrain options to choose from, you’ll be able to get exactly what you want out of this respected model. Choosing its 2.5L BOXER four-cylinder will enhance your experience behind the wheel, with 182 hp propelling you forward with excitement and 176 lb-ft of torque, giving you the strength to tow up to 1,500 lbs. Opting for its 2.0L BOXER hybrid engine delivers the efficiency you’re looking for, getting up to 34 MPG on the highway, providing you with 90 MPGe and 480 total miles of driving range. Even its base 2.0L BOXER four-cylinder is mesmerizing, delivering just the right amount of power and efficiency, making any powertrain able to provide the ride you need and want on any roadway.

Unfortunately, you don’t have as many options in the 2023 Honda HR-V. In fact, you don’t have any choices to make at all. You’re stuck with only one engine that sits underneath the hood of every HR-V, a 2.0L four-cylinder, which produces only 158 hp, meaning the ride inside is bound to leave you wanting more. You won’t find a hybrid option either, but fear not, this small traveler can still hold its own on city streets and highways, getting up to 26 MPG in the city and 32 MPG on the highway. We would like to see a wider array of engine options when it comes to being able to get more of the ride you desire in the HR-V, but unfortunately, Honda doesn’t provide this, which vastly limits your capabilities on the road and off.

Off-Road Prowess

Speaking of off-roading, drivers love the fact that the Crosstrek is perfectly capable of transitioning from highway driving to off-road exploring in an instant. All Crosstreks feature standard Symmetrical All-Wheel Drive capabilities, which are some of the best AWD abilities in their class. No matter the terrain it’s navigating, the Crosstrek’s iconic AWD system can add immense control, traction, and stability to your ride. Constantly adjusting to the changes in the terrain, the Crosstrek sends continuous power to all four wheels, allowing you to hug the curves of the road, maneuver over uneven terrain, and safely travel through bad weather without missing a beat.

Another downfall of the HR-V is that it doesn’t offer all-wheel drive capabilities as standard equipment across its trim levels. This is an available feature but a welcomed one if you’re frequently traversing rough roadways or through inclement weather. Coupled with hill descent control, you’ll be able to navigate challenging environments easily; however, it would help if Honda made these features standard.

Unfortunately for the HR-V, it just can’t keep up with all the exciting performance features found in the 2023 Subaru Crosstrek. From an abundance of engine options to standard all-wheel drive capabilities, the Crosstrek has it all. In addition, it showcases a confident ride quality, accentuated by responsive handling, quiet powertrains, and a firm suspension system. If you want to enjoy any type of ride, the 2023 Subaru Crosstrek is the SUV to have by your side during every mile.

A blue 2023 Subaru Crosstrek Limited parked near a waterfall as its passengers admire the view

Safety

Subaru’s EyeSight Driver Assist Technology

It’s no secret that Subaru features some of the most impressive safety scores in the nation. Whether you’re admiring the 2023 Subaru Crosstrek’s durable build or its state-of-the-art safety systems, it’ll be immediately apparent that the Crosstrek is designed to keep you secure behind the wheel. Not only is the Crosstrek excellently balanced, but it also sits on a rigid chassis to ensure maximum control and safety on the road. This level of rugged durability places the Subaru ahead of the rest and makes it a frequent Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS) Top Safety Pick.

Through standard EyeSight Driver Assist technology, the Crosstrek acts like a true assistant on the road, whether you’re maneuvering through traffic on the interstate or trekking around obstacles in the wilderness. This award-winning safety technology showcases helpful features to enhance your ride, like Pre-Collision Throttle Management to reduce engine power to mitigate damage when vehicles in front of you quickly hit the brakes. Lane Keep Assist keeps you safely in your lane, alerting you if you’ve crossed the line, while Pre-Collision Braking can apply full braking force to help reduce the impact during an accident. Earning the highest possible front crash prevention rating by the IIHS, this level of safety technology is quite unlike anything you’ll come across in the industry.

The Honda Sensing Suite

If you want a vehicle that will last and provide you with a safe ride for miles, it’s difficult to compete with a Subaru; however, the 2023 Honda HR-V showcases a fine lineup of safety features of its own to intensify the competition between these two rivals. Through Honda Sensing, you’ll be able to take advantage of a set of advanced features to improve security on the road, like a Collision Mitigation Braking System, as well as a Road Departure Mitigation System to help reduce damage caused by the unfortunate instance of a crash. A Blind Spot Information System comes in handy to help provide enhanced visibility in hard-to-see areas, while a multi-angle rearview camera offers clear views behind you, which is especially helpful when you’re attempting to navigate out of parking spaces on packed city streets.

Although the HR-V offers its own set of advanced safety features, it doesn’t come with standard all-wheel drive, like you’ll find in the Crosstrek, which makes it difficult to safely traverse dangerous road conditions. If you want a solid foundation and unmatched reliability, the 2023 Subaru Crosstrek will provide this to you. There’s a reason why 97% of Subarus purchased within the last ten years are still faithfully on the road, and this is due to the incredible lineup of safety and assistance features coupled with durability that can’t be replicated, all of which can be found in the 2023 Crosstrek.

Parked near a trailhead, the cargo space of a 2023 Subaru Crosstrek has plenty of room for camping gear

Versatility

A Functional Experience in the Crosstrek

The 2023 Subaru Crosstrek is as versatile as they come, with a well-laid-out cabin space that provides the perfect blend of style and function. From plenty of legroom for all on board, plus an abundance of space to handle all your gear, 55.3 cu.ft. to be exact, the Crosstrek can take on anything coming your way during the drive. With more interior volume than many of its competitors, the Crosstrek can easily deliver the comfort your passengers need without their travel belongings getting in the way. Configurable seating by way of 60/40-split flat-folding rear seats and a wide rear gate makes it easy to load up and get going, even when you’re hauling around cumbersome cargo. Plus, with standard raised roof rails, carrying everything from mountain bikes to kayaks, camping gear, and more is no sweat for this rugged road tripper.

A Comfortable Experience in the HR-V

The 2023 Honda HR-V showcases a modern interior cabin design, but the biggest downside this year is the elimination of the second-row Magic Seats. This handy feature is configured to create a low cargo floor to accommodate more gear, and unfortunately, it’s gone. That’s a big disadvantage for this small-size traveler, and because of this, it can only handle up to 55.1 cu.ft. of cargo; this is less than rivals, like the Crosstrek, as well as previous HR-V models. Plenty of storage compartments can be found, though, to make up for the lack of a Magic Seat; however, this is a big disappointment for many Honda drivers, one that eliminates the HR-V’s ability to lead its class in versatility and cargo capacity. If you’re looking for a versatile subcompact SUV to offer you the perfect blend of convenience and function, the 2023 Crosstrek outperforms the HR-V here.